Gold’s Safe-Haven Role Is Being Stress-Tested by Meme-Style Trading

Key takeaways

• Gold’s sharp rallies and record one-day swings are blurring its “safe haven” profile
• StoneX’s David Scutt said momentum trading pushed gold towards more “risk asset” like behaviour
• Gold was moving faster partly owing to a speculative like interest in the metal

Gold has spent centuries as a store of value, but the price action investors have seen in early 2026 looks closer to “meme stock” dynamics than traditional haven behaviour. StoneX market analyst David Scutt (FOREX.com) told CNN that the recent surge is “distorting gold’s historic role as a haven,” with trading now  more resembling a momentum-led market “at the extremities of the risk asset spectrum.”

What’s Driving the Meme-Style Moves

Gold pushed through record highs in late January before suffering its largest single-day drop on record in late January, though it was still up roughly 15% for the year at the time of publication.

The CNN article pointed to a mix of factors behind the whipsaw, including heightened geopolitical tension, heavy participation from a broad set of traders, and the ease of using exchange-traded products to trade metals like stocks.

That “stock-like” access matters. AS CNN noted, strong inflows into a major gold ETF are reinforcing how quickly positioning can build when a crowded trade takes hold.

Is Momentum Trading Eroding Gold's Hedge Appeal?

Scutt's view is that a hedge should not be the most volatile line item in your portfolio. When traders are piling in on breakouts, gold starts behaving less like “insurance” and more like a crowded trade. And crowded trades can unwind fast.

Keep an Eye on the Cross-Asset Rotation

CNN also highlighted bitcoin’s steep pullback from its prior peak, raising the possibility that some speculative capital rotated from crypto into metals, adding another accelerant to gold and silver’s volatility.

For investors and hedgers, the wise move may be separating the long-term case for gold from the short-term mechanics now driving day-to-day movement. In the near term, positioning, volatility measures, and flows may matter as much as macro headlines.

Access More Global Macro Insights, Forecasts and Tools
Stay connected to timely global macro analysis designed to help market participants navigate shifting economic conditions and evolving risk. Gain access to regular market commentary, updated quarterly forecasts, a comprehensive two-week forward economic event calendar, and specialised tools built to support informed trading and risk management decisions.
[Sign Up]

Read the original article here.

---Written by: Andy Catsimanes

---Expert: David Scutt, Senior Market Analyst, Global Macro