StoneX logo

A Natural Gas Crisis in Europe: How Bad Does It Look?

By: Harry Altham, Energy Analyst, Market Analysis EMEA & Asia

A Natural Gas Crisis in Europe: How Bad Does It Look?
 
Harry Altham
Energy Analyst, EMEA & Asia

This morning’s IEA market report brought about some interesting statements regarding the consequences of rising gas prices in Europe, namely that it predicts 300k bbd of crude oil will be used instead of high-priced natural gas in industrial production across the continent until the beginning of Q1 2023. The news has pushed Brent into positive territory basis last night’s settlement, but we are also seeing a relative weakening in 2023 futures against the October 2022 contract on the assumption that the substitution effect will diminish into the new year. Oil and coal are thought to have the capacity to replace 30BCM of natural gas (21% of Germany’s total pre-war imports [and 60% of Russia’s gas] converted to 3.2M bbd oil equivalent) this winter before adversely impacting the E.U.’s climate goals. Coal consumption is expected to rise by 7% in 2022, which means oil would be expected to fill any shortfall. 

A LOOK THROUGH THE GERMAN LENS
However, we are sceptical that there will be a shortfall of natural gas in the first place   particularly using the example of Germany, where economists are primarily concerned. It would require a severe worst-case combination of a cold winter (considered unlikely by meteorologists as we have just exited a La Niña jet stream cycle), a total halt of flows from Russia (possible, not probable), and a long-term failure of major LNG gasification or liquefaction terminals for Germany’s tanks to run dry. Overall, there is enough LNG terminal capacity in Europe to replace Russian gas, and though much of this is in Iberia / Italy and without sufficient pipeline capacity to transport to Germany, there is sufficient capacity to meet what we predict the doomsday scenario fundamental deficit in Europe’s largest gas consuming nation to be.
These findings use assumptions that flows from Russia will be completely shut off throughout the winter – a scenario that we consider unlikely but is a critical factor in European gas markets. Above €200/MWh, Dutch TTF prices are currently eight times above their five year seasonal average. The raw data is implying an almost unimaginable risk premium; news of restricted flows through any Gazprom owned pipeline continues to expose price sensitivity in the market. But we think the present situation is not quite as critical as many are reporting.
image 46250
Dutch TTF price versus five-year seasonal average. Source: Bloomberg
GERMANY MAKING GOOD PROGRESS IN FILLING ITS TANKS
Firstly, though flows via Nord Stream 1 have been reduced to 20% of capacity (30.7MCM/d), Germany’s gas storage tanks are now 73.7% full (up by 9.5% in a month that included a three-day period in which gas was drawn as quickly as it was being replenished). Germany is filling 1% of its storage tanks every 2.4 days (in spite of the impact on Nord Stream 1), meaning it is currently predicted to achieve 90% storage capacity utilisation before the first calendar day of autumn. Economy Minister Robert Habeck has set a new target of 95% storage utilisation by 1st November, which is around the seven year seasonal peak of gas storage utilisation in Germany – a target which, save for any further unforeseen outages (which constitutes the existing risk premium to Dutch TTF futures prices), is comfortably within reach. 
EVEN WITHOUT CONTINGENCY MEASURES, GERMANY WOULD LIKELY SURVIVE THE WINTER. THAT DOESN'T MEAN IT SHOULD TAKE ANY RISKS!
Turning to demand, the greatest seasonal depletion on record in Germany is 196TWh, equivalent to 80% of storage capacity. On average, Germany’s storage tanks are large enough to cover over 50% of winter seasonal consumption, which is typically supported by further imports throughout the winter. If we assume that 70% of Germany’s gas flow (the non-Russian portion) will continue as normal, the country would have run out of gas in one of the ten previous winters (based on 2022 predicted storage levels and prior years’ consumption). That said, Germany’s capacity to import more gas from alternative sources has improved since 2018 (a new pipeline from Norway is a considerable factor), and it remains unlikely that Russia would completely halt gas exports as the revenue it generates will take on increasing importance for its economy (particularly as seaborne oil will no longer flow to Europe from January 2023, hurting revenues). 
That the IEA predicts oil will replace 3BCM of Germany’s gas consumption (2%) and factoring in a 7% expected rise in coal consumption, leads us to believe with a 99% confidence interval that Germany will ultimately survive the winter with gas remaining in its tanks, even during a cold-winter event. Moreover, the Government is putting into place extensive gas-saving measures which have not been factored in this analysis, which further shores up Germany’s position. However, the situation remains volatile and risky for Germany; in our opinion the energy-saving measures the country is taking are an absolute necessity as a means of ensuring energy security. 
eUROPE GAS FUNDAMENTALS TABLE
image 46251
Source: GIE, Bloomberg
In terms of Europe as a whole, although there are a number of countries whose storage capacity utilisation lags behind the European average of 72.8%, the evidence suggests that almost all E.U. nations will have filled their tanks above the 80% threshold by 1st November. The only country that looks to be struggling in the E.U. is Austria, although it has the option of ramping up imports via Adriatic Sea LNG ports – notably in Rovigo (Italy) and Krk Island (Croatia). The countries at greatest risk of gas shortages in the winter are Bulgaria and Romania; both under political pressure from Moscow and (currently) have a 70%+ dependency on Russia for its gas imports. A new pipeline is being constructed to transfer gas from LNG terminals in the Greek Aegean; Bulgaria’s energy security heavily depends on its completion in November. 
image 46257
Source: GIE, SoneX
what this all means for prices
Firstly, the substitution effect per the IEA report is undoubtedly bullish for Brent. From tomorrow, the Rhine’s water level is expected to fall to a level which makes commercial traffic impossible, meaning that rising industrial demand for oil in Germany is being met by a technical inability to supply it to those areas in need. No rain is forecast, and temperatures in the Rhine Valley are expected to reach 35C this week. Brent’s near-dated prices could see a sharp spike in the coming days, keep an eye on the ARA inventory data over the coming weeks as a possible cause of price spikes in the oil benchmarks. 
Natural gas is being driven as much by the headlines as the fundamentals at present. Flows (or lack thereof) through Yamal and Nord Stream 1 are elevating prices significantly (in our view excessively), but we are now approaching the autumn – where seasonal demand considerations come into play. In the event of an early drop in temperatures, we could see price shocks that far exceed those of the post-invasion period in March – which could spell serious trouble for European economies already pressurised by high inflation.
  • Energy

This material should be construed as market commentary and represents the opinions and viewpoints of the author, and does not reflect tailored advice associated with any specific account.


The views are current only through the date stated and are subject to change at any time based upon market or other conditions, and StoneX Group Inc. (“SGI”) disclaims any responsibility to update such views. Actual results, performance, or achievements may differ materially from those expressed or implied. Information is based on data gathered from what we believe are reliable sources. Past performance does not guarantee future results.


The StoneX Group Inc. group of companies provides financial services worldwide through its subsidiaries, including physical commodities, securities, exchange-traded and over-the-counter derivatives, risk management, global payments and foreign exchange products in accordance with applicable law in the jurisdictions where services are provided.


References to certain OTC products or swaps are made on behalf of StoneX Markets, LLC (SXM), a member of the National Futures Association (NFA) and provisionally registered with the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as a swap dealer. SXM’s products are designed only for individuals or firms who qualify under CFTC rules as an ‘Eligible Contract Participant’ and who have been accepted as customers of SXM.


StoneX Financial Inc. (SFI) is a member of FINRA/NFA/SIPC and registered with the MSRB. SFI is registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) as a Broker-Dealer and with the CFTC as a Futures Commission Merchant and Commodity Trading Advisor. StoneX Financial (Canada) Inc. (SFCI) is registered in Canada and is a member of CIRO and CIPF. References to certain securities trading are made on behalf of the BD Division of SFI and are intended only for an audience of institutional clients as defined by FINRA Rule 4512(c). References to certain exchange-traded futures and options are made on behalf of the FCM Division of SFI. Wealth Management is offered through SA Stone Wealth Management Inc., member FINRA/SIPC, and SA Stone Investment Advisors Inc., an SEC-registered investment advisor, both wholly owned subsidiaries of SGI.

R.J. O’Brien & Associates, LLC (RJO) is registered with the CFTC as a Futures Commission Merchant and is a member of NFA.


StoneX Financial Ltd (SFL) is registered in England and Wales, company no. 5616586. SFL is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) (registration number FRN:446717) to provide services to professional and eligible customers including: arrangement, execution and, where required, clearing derivative transactions in exchange traded futures and options. SFL is also authorized to engage in the arrangement and execution of transactions in certain OTC products, certain securities trading, precious metals trading and payment services to eligible customers. SFL is authorized and regulated by the FCA under the Payment Services Regulations 2017 for the provision of payment services. SFL is a category 1 ring-dealing member of the London Metal Exchange. In addition SFL also engages in other physically delivered commodities business and other general business activities which are unregulated and not required to be authorized by the FCA.


This communication is issued in the European Economic Area by StoneX Financial Europe GmbH (SFEG). StoneX is the trade name used by STONEX GROUP INC. and all its associated entities and subsidiaries. StoneX Financial Europe GmbH (“SFEG”) is a securities trading firm registered in Germany under Company No. HRB 80844.


StoneX APAC Pte. Ltd. (“SAP”) (Co. Reg. No 200616676W) is regulated as a Dealer (PS20190001002) under the Precious Stones and Precious Metals (Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing) Act 2019 for purposes of anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism. SAP is an “Approved International Trading Company” authorized to act as a “Spot Commodity Broker” under the Commodity Trading Act.


StoneX Financial Pte Ltd (Co. Reg. No 201130598R) (“SFP”) is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore and is a Capital Markets Service Licence holder (for dealing in capital market products), an Exempt Financial Adviser (for advising on investment products and issuing or promulgating analyses/ reports on investment products) and a Major Payment Institution (for domestic and cross-border money transfer services).


SFP may distribute analysis/report produced by its respective foreign affiliates within the StoneX Group of companies pursuant to an arrangement under Regulation 32C of the Financial Advisers Regulations Recipients should contact SFP at (65) 6309 1000 for any matters arising from, or in connection with, this webinar.


StoneX APAC Pte. Ltd. (“SAP”) (Co. Reg. No 200616676W) is regulated as a Dealer (PS20190001002) under the Precious Stones and Precious Metals (Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism Financing) Act 2019 for purposes of anti-money laundering and countering the financing of terrorism.


StoneX Financial (HK) Limited (CE No.: BCQ152) (“SHK”) is regulated by the Hong Kong Securities and Futures Commission for Dealing in Securities and Dealing in Futures Contracts.


StoneX Financial Pty Ltd (ACN 141 774 727) holds an Australian Financial Service License (AFSL: 345646) for Dealing in Securities, Exchange-Traded Derivatives Contracts, OTC Derivatives Contracts and Foreign Exchange Contracts, and is regulated by the Australian Securities and Investments Commission.


StoneX Securities Co., Ltd. (“SSJ”) (Co. Reg. No 010401047199) is regulated by the Japanese Financial Services Agency as a Type-I Financial Instruments Business Operator (Kanto Local Finance Bureau (FIBO)No.291’), is a member of the Financial Futures Association of Japan for dealing and broking FX and FX Option transactions, and is a member of the Japan Securities Dealers Association for dealing and broking stock indices and option transactions.


Trading swaps and over-the-counter derivatives, exchange-traded derivatives and options and securities involves substantial risk and is not suitable for all investors. Past performance of any futures or option is not indicative of future success. Indicators are not a trading system and are not published as a specific trade recommendation. The information herein is not a recommendation to trade nor investment research or an offer to buy or sell any derivative or security. It does not take into account your particular investment objectives, financial situation or needs and does not create a binding obligation on any of the StoneX group of companies to enter into any transaction with you. You are advised to perform an independent investigation of any transaction to determine whether any transaction is suitable for you. No part of this material may be copied, photocopied or duplicated in any form by any means or redistributed without the prior written consent of StoneX Group Inc.


The report/analysis herein is not directed to, or intended for distribution to or use by, any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law or regulation.


© 2026 StoneX Group Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Satellite view of Earth at night showing illuminated cities across Asia and the Middle East

Discover more insights

Our subscribers have access to comprehensive market analysis from StoneX spanning commodities, equities, currencies and more.

Related articles for Energy

WTI and Brent Crude Are Now Reading the Strait of Hormuz Differently

WTI and Brent crude are moving to different beats as a possible U.S. Iran deal reshapes the oil market. The two benchmarks are pricing Strait of Hormuz risk in their own ways, and the gap between them says a lot about where crude goes next.

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
  • Energy

Perspective: Morning Commentary for August 7

August 7 – The U.S. economy unexpectedly lost 23k jobs in July, dramatically below market expectations of an 80k increase and marking the worst Non-Farm Payrolls print since February. Furthermore, May and June were both revised sharply downward, with combined revisions showing 103k fewer jobs than previously reported. Outside of the healthcare sector, which added 22k jobs in July, the losses were very broad-based. Government payrolls saw the largest decline, shedding 53k jobs in July, the largest seen since October 2025, while June was revised down to show a loss of 10k jobs as well. The private sector at least saw growth, adding 30k jobs in July, now matching the month prior after it was revised down from the 49k initially reported, and substantially missing forecasts of 78k jobs being added. This is a sharp reversal in course from the largely better than expected U.S. labor data seen earlier this week.

Mike Castle
Mike Castle
  • Grains & Oilseeds
  • Energy
  • Dairy
  • Renewable Fuels
  • Cocoa
  • Coffee
  • Cotton
  • Sugar
  • Meats & Livestock
  • Forest Products

Diesel Supply Faces Three Fresh Risks Before the Winter Heating Season

The oil market keeps watching the Strait of Hormuz, but the tighter pressure on fuel is building in refining. With a large share of global capacity offline and unplanned outages carrying no repair timeline, diesel supply faces three fresh risks before winter.

Editorial Team
Editorial Team
  • Energy
StoneX: We open markets

Our market expertise, advanced platforms, global reach, culture of full transparency and commitment to our clients’ success all set us apart in the financial marketplace.

Reach

With access to 40+ derivatives exchanges, 180+ foreign exchange markets, nearly every global securities marketplace and numerous bi-lateral liquidity venues, StoneX’s digital network and deep relationships can take clients anywhere they want to go.

Transparency

As a publicly traded company meeting the highest standards of regulatory compliance in the markets we serve, our financials and record of accomplishment are matters of public record. StoneX’s commitment to “doing the right thing over the easy thing” sets us apart in the industry and helps us build respect, client trust and new partnerships.

Expertise

From our proprietary Market Intelligence platform, to “boots on the ground” expertise from award-winning traders and professionals, we connect our clients directly to actionable insights they can use to make more informed decisions and achieve their goals in the global markets.