Major global phosphate export location price graphs
I will say this now and will say it going forward to eternity: these are the flat price graphs for each individual location. Your price where you are is going to be different. There are logistics. There is the cost of storage/interest/insurance/etc. These graphs should not be taken as "it shows the price at $700, why isn't my price $700". These graphs should be used to give an appreciation for price movements.
All values are in metric tons and USD currency.
What everyone wants to know first, what do we think will happen going forward
Global
While I never thought phosphate values would drop forever, I thought they would drop further than they did. We have obviously seen a bounce in recent weeks/months...but I struggle with it. If Chinese exports are returning and India is well ahead on imports vs average, I think we could slide right back to where we were.
Our outlook remains cautiously bearish going forward.
That isn't to say that we cannot see a bit of a short term tic higher. Just when I look a bit further on the calendar, there are a lot more reasons to be bearish than bullish today.
North America
N.A. is still in a weird situation as the U.S. continues to effectively block 3 of the biggest phosphate exporters in the world: China / Russia / Morocco. That, combined with very low ending inventories from last spring, has the current market tight. Doesn't help that those in the wheat belt and those reliant on the Upper Mississippi River are backed into a corner with time running out.
Near term should continue to see values flat to bullish. Longer term should see values starting to slide.
Like the world, I am not confident in the long term view of this marketplace. Values are too high and major importers ahead of schedule. Seems to me a slide will resume.
Should you buy your phosphate needs?
If the current values work for your operation/region/etc., then that is your answer. Your local market needs to be considered as things like supply availability, demand timing and logistical issues can change the view. Just because we see the market strong or weak going forward does not mean it will translate to where you live. We are all a part of the world, but we live at home.
Global
Phosphate values are down HUGE from this time last year. They are down even more when compared to the high's of April 2022.
However, that just looks at that period. When we look at phosphate values even further back, when times were "normal", they were lower still...and that is where my head is today.
Unless you need the product near term (this calendar year), it is hard for me to get excited about it.
Honestly, I continue to look at the global S&D...and it makes me question why we are so high priced. I know there is a bit of "well, it is so much higher than last year" but it is still high. I think there is more downward work to do.
North America
If my POV on the global side is that values are too high, that means worse things for N.A. given how much of a premium NOLA is vs the world.
Be aware that supplies are still snug today, could be tight into fall but longer term/2024, sure looks like values will continue to settle down.
Now, let's put this into context. I'm not seeing a situation where the price fall hundreds of dollars between today and spring. Just for the fun of it, let's imagine we think the price will fall $100. What does that mean on a per acre basis? The math I ran reflects a cost per acre that is less than 2 bushels of corn.
Now, I know we have to watch every dollar. Every freaking thing out there costs a ton today. We have to look at it as a business. If delaying your fall application into spring might cost you more than 2 bushels of corn per acre top end yield, you might save the $100 flat price but still "lose". This has to be a region/farmer/field decision. While I think the price likely trends lower after Christmas, there are a lot of benefits to getting it applied in the fall.
Guess what I'm saying is look at the broad picture.
CME Futures settlement indications
While the fertilizer futures market is far from as liquid as its grain counterparts, it is still active and gives us an insight into what the market is thinking.
Please note that the values below can and will change daily. This is merely a look at where they are as of writing:
| | NOLA DAP |
| September | $517.50 |
| October | $507.50 |
| November | - |
| December | - |
| January | $482.50 |
| February | $482.50 |
| March | $482.50 |
general global dap/map information
What has happened in the last 30 days?
Chinese exports still behind average thru July...but improved over last year
A quick background on China for those new to the newsletter.
Last year, China was the 2nd largest exporter of DAP/MAP in the world, falling behind Morocco. However, 2022 was a abnormal year. Typically, China is by far the world's largest producer and exporter of DAP/MAP and it isn't even close. The thing that changed 2022 was the Chinese governments restricting exports. As global phosphate values skyrocketed and product became scarce, the government stepped up and made the restrictions in an effort to provide adequate supplies at a discounted price to Chinese farmers. While I'm usually not one that wants government interference on free markets...the plan worked. Chinese domestic farmers saw values lower than the world with enough product to go around. However, the world paid the price with their annual export total nearly 5M less than typical.
Since then, the restrictions have been scaled back as world prices fell and product became available again. There simply hasn't been a need of intervention. But that doesn't mean they are back to full strength.
Looking at the graph below, you see where exports thru July are a little over 1MMT lower than the 2019 - 2021 average. For some, they view this as a bullish scenario with it meaning that China is refusing to reclaim their previous export flows. Others are looking and seeing significant improvement vs last year which means a lot more product "should" be available to the world thru the rest of 2023.
I cannot tell you what will happen by the end of December. Today, it looks like exports will continue, albeit at a slightly slower pace. As they resume their rightful place at the top of global exporters, the world S&D gets back to normal which means values should get back to normal. On the flip side, if we start seeing/hearing more restrictions being put into place, we need to see the writing on the wall that firmer phosphate markets could be coming.
As always, markets half a world away can affect every farming operation around the world.
India continues to import ahead of normal / Brazil on pace
If we care so much about how well one of the world's largest exporters are doing, it makes sense to pay attention to the world's largest buyer...right?!
India sits alone as the world's biggest importer and number 2, Brazil, isn't close. However, Brazil is extremely far ahead of the number 3 spot so a lot of world phosphate import can be tracked by these two countries.
Starting with India, they continue the hot import pace that was set in their last fertilizer year. Although they are only 3 months into this new fertilizer year, they are already a few hundred thousand tons ahead of schedule. Combined with the aggressive pace from last year, it could mean a situation is brewing where India demand dries up earlier than normal, leaving the global phosphate market to sit and ponder when the next demand will step forward...never a good situation for those wanting higher prices.
However, I have to admit that some more intelligent than I are saying that Indian phosphate stockpiles are actually low with solid domestic demand. If that is the case or even the governments perceived view, the buying slow down may not occur.
For Brazil, they are nearly even to their 3-year average import pace thru July. There really isn't a reason to look at them and think that their demand will spike or wane in the near future.
While I do not know for sure, the ahead of average import pace for India does have me conservative on my outlook. If they start scaling back their purchases, long positions can start to get very nervous very quickly. Remaining demand points around the world will see a lot more attention.
Global trade flows still in flux as U.S. duties against Russia/China/Morocco remain
Chalk this one up to the U.S.
There was one event that really kicked off the last 3 years of these insane markets on the fertilizer side: U.S. imposing counter vailing duties against Morocco and Russia, joining China which already had duties in place.
The case was filed with reasons given that Morocco was not having to adhere to the same environmental standards as U.S. producers and Russia was getting inputs at a significantly lower value that free market pricing. While this might anger some, the case WAS valid. Florida producers are required to keep their gypsum stacks (by product of phosphate production) contained to keep it from contaminating surrounding areas. They also must reclaim the land that they mine. A great example of this is the Streamsong golf course in Florida. Mosaic reclaimed the land and built a beautiful golf course in its place. While a phenomenal course, this requires a lot of capital. They are also subjected to free market input values. If others are not required to the same standard, it puts domestic producers at a significant disadvantage which is why I make that comment.
However, that doesn't mean the impact isn't felt.
The result of the counter vailing duty rates has been that the top three exporters of DAP/MAP in the world are largely unable to come to the U.S. While much of the past two year near record high values are attributed to global events (it wasn't just N.A. values high), N.A. is operating at a higher value vs the world. That has been especially true recently with low ending spring inventories.
For many other buyers around the world, this has been a blessing of sorts. With the U.S. cutting off these imports, it means those three exporters need to get more aggressive in the remaining markets which lowers price ideas.
There are still 2 years left on the current U.S. counter vailing duty with no signs of it being disrupted which means this situation will continue for the foreseeable future. What happens at the end of the 5 year life is anyone's guess. Some theorize the duties will be allowed to end and a return to normal happens. Others theorize the duties will be refreshed and continued for years to come. In the end, it is all just that: theorizing. No one knows. It just makes for interesting coffee shop talk.
But as long as they continue, it will continue to disrupt normal and efficient trade flows around the world.
N.A. inventories still tight and high prices nearby
As was also the case with potash and urea, phosphate ended the spring season about as low on ending inventory than any year I can remember in my 20+ year history. Typically, near the end of spring, values start to slide as remaining long positions puke to make sales and stay ahead of competition. Better to give up some money on the nearby than to hold onto it for several months out of fear of what could happen in the summer.
This last spring was not typical. Not only did prices not slide, values rose decently toward the end of spring and multiple regions across N.A. reported difficulty in getting product in a decent timeframe at a decent price. Effectively, it turned into an auction for those with product with the question "who is willing to pay the most" being asked. Not hard to see why values jumped.
That situation continues to affect phosphate today. This is even more prevalent for nearby demand like wheat country and those reliant on the Upper Mississippi River for logistics. Time is against these markets and the distribution side of the market knows it. Want product sooner than later? It's going to cost you...
I wish that wasn't the case. That is the case.
A lot of question now is how long this tight supply situation will last. The short answer is "it depends":
- Will Morocco send product to the U.S.? - obviously, with their 15% duty on phosphate imports, it makes it difficult. However, when you look at how much of a premium NOLA DAP is (MAP significantly higher still), it seems as though they could pay the 15% penalty and still have a better netback than most other global regions. However, if they do that and start importing significant volumes, they lose a bit of footing on their argument against the CVD rate. They have been vocal about it for the last 3 years and continue to fight today. The problem is, if they start importing now, that 3 years worth of arguments goes out the window to a certain extent. Without those imports acting as a supply boost and competition against domestic producers, it is a bit more of a free for all.
- What does demand look like? - this depends on the area. I am talking about replacement values...and there are still a lot of stories of retailers who are selling at the original fill price. No, seriously. Lot of folks like to beat up the retailer when prices hang but no one ever talks about when retailers keep the price cheap in a rising market. This has been heard across N.A. It isn't everywhere, but it is enough to point out. If retailers have moved their price up, there is a solid case to be made that fall demand is going to scale back an help balance the S&D. If retailers keep the price "low", demand will not change. If corn prices rise, it helps build demand. If corn prices fall, demand gets hurt. There are a lot of factors which can fundamentally change the outlook.
- How does the world continue in the coming weeks/months? - obviously by the price graphs on this newsletter, global phosphate values have turned a corner higher. Will this continue, even with Chinese exports resuming? Will the rising price cause more demand to step in or will it scare it away. N.A. is a part of the global complex so while we can move to a premium/discount vs the world, we still ebb and flow with it.
All of this to say "don't sleep on phosphate". Do not think that we can wait until November to walk in, check in hand, and demand our fields be fertilized. There is decent price risk in the phosphate market today (see below for more info on that). Last year stunk, for lack of a better description. The forward futures market is indicating at last a $40 discount vs today's values.
I'm not saying we have to lock in our fall needs but if spring taught us anything, those further away from production points (west/north) need to have more conversations with their retailers about their wants/needs for the remainder of 2023.
Current phosphate values "high" vs many comparisons
I'm going to start his section by saying this: this does not mean that global/domestic phosphate values cannot move higher. If the last few years have taught us anything, it is to expect the unexpected.
That out of the way...
Alright, let's get into the meat of why I think that.
Globally, phosphate values had fallen nearly constantly since April 2022. In recent weeks, values have turned a corner and shown a little strength. If we just look at price data since the start of 2022, this recent bump looks like nothing and shows phosphate still being decently well valued.
Now, if we step back a little further, the picture changes. While values are significantly lower than the recent high's, they are certainly elevated when we expand the chart to 2015. However, things change in the world. Inflation is a very real thing so what was "normal" in the past may not be normal in the future.
So let's get away from the flat price comparison of phosphate. I preach that in my presentations, I should probably live it as well!
It is when I start comparing current values of DAP and MAP against grains like corn where it really captures my attention. Take a look at the ratio charts below. They have gotten back to the high side for DAP and are well into the high side of MAP. If replacement values are flowing down to the farmgate, there is a very real possibility that fall demand could be lower than expected with farmers decided to either delay or reduce applications.
Again, I'm not saying values cannot go higher. The last two years taught us that.
I guess I'm just trying to justify my POV on the phosphate market being bearish longer term.